Monday, January 20, 2025

Arts minister Gayton McKenzie promises fixes, admits South Africa's government failed artists: ‘They can't even open an Ellerines account’


by Thinus Ferreira

South Africa's arts and culture minister Gayton McKenzie has slammed the country's government for its failure to reform the entertainment industry and the system to prevent artists from suffering and perpetually dying in poverty.

Gayton McKenzie spoke at the funeral of singer Winnie Khumalo (51) and said the government is serious about fixing South Africa's broken entertainment biz system this year.

Winnie Khumalo died 7 January after a short illness and without a medical aid, followed by the death two days later of Victor "Doc Shebeleza" Bogopane after a long illness.

Gayton McKenzie branded The Cultural and Creative Industries Federation of South Africa (CCIFSA) – a representative body funded by the department of sports, arts and culture – as a "criminal organisation" that he said got millions of rands from the government with little to show for it.

"Artists in this country, you have been failed by us – your government," Gayton McKenzie said at the funeral service.

"I'm not pointing fingers at others – I’m part of government. We have failed you. We have failed artists in this country as a government."

"Let me tell you how have we have failed you: How come artists in this country can't even open an Ellerines account? They don't have a three months' bank statements. Artists in this country are not being seen as workers. How can that be? We have failed you."

"I came here for two reasons. I came to apologise because I am part of the people who have failed you. But I'm also going to be part of the people that bring the solution and fix what we have done wrong," he said.

"I send my sincerest apology because artists are being treated like nothing."

"Artists die.They are represented CCIFSA. Why can't CCIFSA pay for the funerals of artists? They're getting millions. Millions and millions and millions. They steal from artists."

Gayton McKenzie said "CCIFSA is a criminal organisation. I have the bank statements of how many millions they've got but the artists are still poor. Why did you get all these millions?"

"I will bring out the bank statements of how much you have been paid over all these years. You got millions and millions and millions. Where's that money? What have you done with that money?" 

At the funeral the veteran musician and producer Chicco Twala also spoke and revealed Winnie Khumalo suffered and had no medical aid.

"What we have are burial aids. Not medical aids. They only put money aside for us when we are dead. Winnie did not deserve to die the way she did. She suffered. Rethabile suffered alone. I saw Winnie two days before she passed on; what I saw was not okay. Winnie needed a medical aid.

"The likes of Winnie and many of our late musicians who were instrumentally generating millions into our sector deserve better. I want our government to do something about that."

Chicco Twala said "There are three companies: Universal Music, Warner Brothers, as well as Sony. They have collected more than R1 billion. Money that belongs to musicians like Winnie, producers like Sizwe Zakwe, the late Hugh Masekela. That money, they shared it among themselves and did not pay a cent to producers".

Earlier this month The South African Guild of Actors (SAGA) slammed the government and the minister for the inaction to protect the rights of workers in South Africa's TV and film industry where the casts and crews of several TV shows have gone unpaid for months.

After many months struggling to just get paid and losing homes and rental accommodation and forced to sell cars and equipment, the workers on Paramount Africa and Bakwena Productions' Pound 4 Pound series shown on the BET Africa (DStv 129) channel on MultiChoice's pay-TV service, finally got paid in December.

The cast and crew of Clive Morris Productions' Queendom series, also shown on Paramount Africa's BET, are however again and still waiting to be paid after production had shut down once more – the latest shut down for the troubled show due to people simply not being paid for their work.

The cast and crew of The Executives, produced by Sawita Productions and shown on the South African public broadcaster's SABC1 are also still waiting to be paid, while the cast and crew of Nikiwe, produced for eMedia's e.tv by Thomas Gumede and Lungelo Radu's Parental Advisory Productions are also waiting for payment for over a year. 

Jack Devnarain, SAGA chairperson, said "Nobody wants to step up and admit they failed to protect the rights of performers, crew and background actors".

"The problem is we have normalised silence. If you step back and look at the damage inflicted on the industry through non-payments, there should be all kinds of alarms, sirens, and media statements by the government, ministers wagging their fingers. There should be interventions by industry organisations, but no, none of that is happening – just silence."