Showing posts with label Hong Kong. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hong Kong. Show all posts
Thursday, June 13, 2019
TV CRITIC's NOTEBOOK. Wednesday night I deleted China's CGTN app from my phone after its shocking censorship and news bias became very clear - here's why you should too.
It was weird on Wednesday night when I chose to "delete" the news.
I love the news, especially TV news, and the more different news sources there are, the better for me, for you and for the world.
Yet, on Wednesday I scrolled down the apps list on my phone and clicked "uninstall" on the "news" app of China's CGTN (DStv 409 / StarSat 266) to completely get rid of it.
Somehow I should probably have realised sooner that China's CGTN is not really a news channel but like ANN7 that morphed into Afro Worldview, Russia's RT, and some others, actually a propaganda channel with a specific view and a biased narrative that it is pushing.
With stories like Wednesday's "Chinese soldiers plant trees to run barren island into a paradise" CGTN shamelessly panders to whoever its audience might be, using the semblance of what consumers known as "news" to push propaganda that only makes the Chinese government and its great Xi look good.
It was jarring and jaw-dropping as a South African and African TV news consumer to see in real time BBC World News, Al Jazeera, Sky News, CNN International, France24 and a raft of other channels do live coverage from the disturbing and chaotic scenes in Hong Kong on Wednesday.
As the police fired tear gas and rubber bullets at protestors shown on several TV news channels, CGTN showed recorded travelogue snippets of how beautiful it is in Tibet.
While global TV news channel followed up with filed reports and live crossings to Hong Kong's streets and interviewed protestors and told viewers what is happening, CGTN did fluff-stuff after fluff-stuff of how China is adding more flights to Africa and how Chinese business is uplifting Africa.
Sadly, Africans in traditional tribal gear still only dance like circus acts (and by implication for their dinner) for the Chinese men in their business suits as proudly broadcast on CGTN. Weirdly on CGTN it never happens the other way round.
It was shocking to see how CGTN as a propaganda channel of the Chinese communist government totally controlled and censored the "news" on Wednesday. Not not a single story about the Hong Kong protest was broadcast, not a single mention on the news scroll, not a single story on the CGTN website, or anything on its social media.
While news consumers in Africa and elsewhere in the world have access to multiple other news sources and could follow and were shown what was happening (although CGTN did not), it made me think of how it must be to live in China where news like the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests and the recent anniversary of it, news about Taiwan, and other actual news about and around China are completely blocked, censored and delivered slanted.
On its website CGTN says it's a news source that "gives a balanced view".
Well, on Tuesday and Wednesday there was zero balance on CGTN, just blatant, arrogant, misguided and highly-embarrassing CGTN censorship.
The awkward and blunt CGTN censorship and propaganda, after some research late into Wednesday night, becomes even more clear when you make the effort as a news consumer to take a broader look.
After saying that the recent debate between Trish Regan of Fox Business News and whoever the CGTN anchor was would be broadcast on both channels - live - and announcing and hyping it up beforehand, CGTN literally backed down and bluntly and quietly announced it won't be broadcasting it anymore ... two hours before the time.
CGTN suddenly said it couldn't broadcast the anchors' TV tete-a-tete "because of copyright".
Of course no copyright issues were ever involved, other than China's government and CGTN being scared that Trish might say something on live television or talk about a topic that they don't want Chinese viewers to hear.
Of course there are "good" people and "real" journalists working at CGTN - globally and across Africa. It's sad that they work for a propaganda channel and probably want to do real journalism but are hamstrung by their censorship bosses.
When CGTN Africa's division based in Nairobi, Kenya started and launched the Africa Live broadcasting block, I cheered. Africa Live still does more coverage daily about Africa than most of the other TV news channels.
The problem - hugely evident on Wednesday night - is that at some point however an editorial decision was obviously taken to turn it into pandering, 'newsfomercials' fodder, hijacking the "news" format to do puff-piece China-promoting publicity to Chinese politicians and Chinese business across the African continent instead of news.
While Africa Live does more Africa coverage, a lot of it isn't actually news.
When something in Africa involves the remotest connection to China it's turned into China-prime stories on Africa Live, China's benefactor role is hyped up beyond belief with glowing visuals and language and it's run like China puff-pieces looking exactly like corporate videos but one in which China is the company.
Wednesday night's Africa Live stories about Chinese flights and Chinese brand rakings and Chinese representatives hobnobbing with African politicians were done awfully.
CGTN and CGTN Africa bosses must think that Africa's news consumers are idiots and will just slurp up this contant slanted sludge without pushback or critical thought. Not so.
Consumers in Africa have access to more news sources that don't shamelessly censor and spout propaganda and can see and compare the differences.
By comparison, CGTN with its biased approach looks silly, embarrassing and incapable of bringing and providing real news coverage when it matters.
While I love the news, on Wednesday I realised that I no longer - if I ever did - trust CGTN. I don't trust that CGTN will show me what is news in the world (including China), all the news, and the news accurately, timeously and without censorship.
I don't have time to kowtow and to use and consume and to drag along "news" sources like CGTN on my TV screen or as an app on my cellphone when it clearly shows itself to be useless when it comes to doing what it falsely purports to be: a "news" platform.
Neither should you.
Wednesday, June 12, 2019
China's CGTN news channel on DStv and StarTimes's StarSat shamelessly censors its coverage of the chaotic scenes and protests in Hong Kong while its Africa Live bulletin does pandering coverage of how Chinese business and politicians shine in Africa.
On Wednesday China's global TV news channel, CGTN (DStv 409 / StarSat 266), further damaged what was left of its credibility as a news service by completely ignoring any news regarding the massive public protests in Hong Kong.
CGTN again revealed its shocking and deliberate news bias and active censorship of news the Chinese government doesn't like by giving zero coverage and making no mention of the protests in Hong Kong that got shown everywhere else on Wednesday.
Other global TV news channels from BBC World News, Sky News, Al Jazeera, CNN International and France24 - all available in South Africa and across Africa to viewers through pay-TV services like MultiChoice's DStv, StarTimes and it's StarSat subsidiary in South Africa, as well as others - all covered the protests in Hong Kong.
While CGTN censored the event and did absolutely nothing, they all showed the chaotic scenes, had live visuals, and had various filed stories from reporters in the Hong Kong streets all through Wednesday.
In sharp and highly-embarrassing contrast, CGTN completely blocked out any news and reporting of the protest with no stories on the CGTN website about the protests, not a single mention on the CGTN news broadcasts, and nothing on CGTN social media, pretending as if a big global news event was simply not happening.
CGTN's surreal and shameless censorship and news manipulation continued on Wednesday evening when it's flagship prime time programme, Africa Live, for African audiences and done from Nairobi Kenya with news anchor, Richard Nta.
Africa Live, just like the rest of CGTN, likewise censored the news with no coverage of the protests in Hong Kong and not a single mention during the hour-long Wednesday bulletin.
On Wednesday dramatic scenes unfolded and was broadcast worldwide - except for on CGTN - when violent clashes broke out in the streets after the aggressive Hong Kong police tried to stop protesters storming the city’s parliament and then started firing rubber bullets and teargas on the thousands of protesters.
Hong Kong citizens are against the government's plan to change existing laws to agreed to allow for the extradition of people to China.
Instead of showing African viewers the actual news and what is happening in Hong Kong, CGTN in a surreal display of how far it has become a Chinese government propaganda channel, broadcast insert after insert on Africa Live about how well China's politicians and Chinese business are working with Africa.
Chinese politicians were shown in inserts beaming and shaking hands with Ethiopian counterparts, after which Chinese politicians cozied up to other African leaders in other stories.
Then in a pandering insert, Africans in tribal gear had to dance for Chinese dignitaries in suits on the tarmac in Nairobi, Kenya, in an "infomercial-news" insert celebrating new Chinese flights between Changsha in China and Nairobi in Africa.
That was followed by a story of how wonderful Chinese brands are and how well Chinese brands are doing in Africa and globally.
None of the Africa Live stories regarding China contained any criticism or any actual balance, as the litany of fluff pieces to show how great and wonderful China is, were broadcast as "news" in an unending stream of inserts showing off China as Africa's big benefactor.
ALSO READ: TV CRITIC's NOTEBOOK. Wednesday night I deleted China's CGTN app from my phone after its shocking censorship and news bias became very clear - here's why you should too.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)