by Thinus Ferreira
The South African government's flailing state-funded film agency the National Film and Video Foundation (NFVF) and the unstable National Arts Council (NAC) have failed to spend R337 million in grants.
The financial figures were revealed by the Auditor-General of South Africa (AGSA) during a briefing to parliament's National Council of Provinces (NCOP) select committee on education, sciences and creative industries.
While the NFVF failed to disburse R231.2 million, the NAC left R106.3 million on the table.
The AGSA specifically flagged both entities because the volume of unspent conditional grants points to deeper operational breakdowns in project execution and financial planning, which directly delays support for South Africa's struggling creatives.
Although both agencies are responsible for distributing funds under the Presidential Employment Stimulus Programme (PESP) alongside their standard sector grants for filmmakers, artists, and cultural organisations, the audit presentation did not break down exactly which funding pools the unspent cash belonged to.
Beyond the unspent funds, the audit uncovered persistent administrative weaknesses at both institutions.
Both the NFVF and NAC received unqualified audit opinions with findings, showing zero improvement from the prior financial year.
The NAC initially submitted financial statements containing material errors that were only fixed during the auditing process. It also failed to enforce proper consequence management regarding fruitless and wasteful expenditure.
Furthermore, auditors found material issues in the NFVF's performance reporting, noting that its targets were inconsistently presented and inaccurately described.
The AGSA attributed the ongoing dysfunction across the government's sport, arts and culture portfolio to vacant critical posts, a lack of accountability, and sluggish leadership responses.
The audit findings come during a period of intense upheaval within the sector.
Just weeks before the parliamentary briefing, the sport, arts and culture minister Gayton McKenzie dissolved the NFVF council following the unlawful appointment of a board member as acting CEO and ongoing governance disputes.
Meanwhile, separate parliamentary hearings revealed further cracks in how stimulus funds are managed.
The NAC admitted that it doesn't independently verify the jobs it claims to create, alongside AGSA findings of duplicated and unverifiable beneficiary ID numbers across both agencies' PESP records.
Neither the NFVF nor the NAC had the opportunity to defend their audit records before lawmakers.
Committee chairperson Makhi Feni abruptly adjourned the session after the department's top brass - Gayton McKenzie, deputy minister Peace Mabe, and director-general Cynthia Khumalo - all failed to show up for the accountability meeting.
