by Thinus Ferreira
One flight of fantasy that isn't true is Checkers' Sixty60 delivery ad on TikTok that shows it delivering orders by turquoise Airwolf helicopter to houseboats along the whole West Coast.
South Africa's Advertising Regulatory Board (ARB) upheld a complaint after a consumer complained about "a floating house or houseboat situated on turquoise water somewhere on
the West Coast".
In Checkers' TikTok ad, individuals are shown relaxing on the deck and in the water. During the
scene, the occupants use the Checkers Sixty60 app to place a grocery order. The
advertisement then shows a helicopter arriving to deliver the groceries to the boat".
The complainant who lives in St Helena Bay was upset and said Checkers "in fact do not deliver to 'somewhere in the West Coas. I am in St. Helena Bay, and they
will not deliver to me, which is somewhere in the West Coast. They are also not offering
helicopter delivery".
Checkers explained to the ARB that the ad formed part of its "Summer Delivered" campaign and intentionally used visual hyperbole, nostalgia, and creative licence.
"The
depiction of a helicopter delivering groceries to a floating house is not intended to represent
Sixty60’s actual delivery methods or geographic coverage," Checkers said, "but rather to convey the brand’s
playful, aspirational tone".
Checkers said that "the imagery of a helicopter delivery and the
ocean setting serves as a metaphorical storytelling device".
According to the retailer, the phrase "Summer delivered anywhere" is "figurative language designed to evoke the emotional freedom and spontaneity associated
with summer, not a literal claim that Sixty60 delivers to all locations along the West Coast or
to offshore environments."
"The phrase is meant to evoke the
emotional essence of freedom and joy... rather than as a comprehensive claim of service
availability."
Checkers argued that a reasonable consumer "would not interpret the
advertisement as promising helicopter delivery or delivery to remote coastal areas".
"Delivery is clearly disclosed within the Sixty60 app, ensuring that consumers
have accurate information before placing an order" and that "there was no intention to mislead consumers. The
advertisement contains no pricing, operational guarantees or factual claims about delivery
coverage. Instead, it relies on exaggeration and nostalgic references, including the use of a
Bell 222 helicopter reminiscent of the 1980s television series Airwolf, to create a humorous,
light‑hearted summer narrative."
"There was no intent to mislead. The advertisement employs imaginative visuals that are
widely accepted in advertising as a means to convey brand ethos and emotional connection."
The ARB said Checkers' helicopter delivery in the ad "is so far removed from ordinary grocery delivery (especially in
the South African context) that its use in the advertisement is clearly hyperbolic".
"The advertiser’s explanation that the scene is a nostalgic reference to the 1980s television series
Airwolf reinforces the creative and fantastical nature of the execution."
On the other part the ARB however, found "that while no reasonable consumer expects a helicopter
delivery offshore, the advertisement communicates that any reasonable West Coast
destination would be possible".
"This is due to the identification of a specific area, and the
promise at the end of the advertisement of 'delivery anywhere'. A hypothetical reasonable
consumer works from a presumption that most advertising is trying to communicate
something about the product, and there can be no question that the communication of this
commercial is that the advertiser strives to achieve delivery in the most extreme
circumstances."
"It delivers 'anywhere', and specifically identifies the West Coast in this
regard. If one then considers that, in fact, there are large parts of the West Coast that the advertiser does not deliver to, one is left wondering what the advertisement was actually
trying to communicate," the ARB says.
"The Directorate, therefore, finds that the advertisement is likely to mislead the hypothetical
reasonable consumer into believing that the advertiser offers delivery 'anywhere' along the
West Coast."
The ARB found the Checkers ad in breach of Clause 4.2.1 of Section II of the Code and asked ARB members not to accept the ad with the claims "Somewhere on the West Coast" and "Summer delivery. Anywhere."
