Thursday, August 24, 2023

2023 Silwerskerm Film Festival | Day 1: How kykNET's pivot to include TV will support even more new voices.


by Thinus Ferreira

Ninety-nine years since The Rotunda in Camps Bay was built in 1904, the movers, shakers and moviemakers in South Africa's film biz will once again descend from today on the oldest single-story dome construction in Cape Town for kykNET's 11th Silwerskermfees film festival held in Cape Town.

The Bay Hotel's glass-lined azure pool, ensconced just beyond the palm-tree-lined Victoria Road, once again beckons the wide array of new and longtime film and TV industry professionals who are all coming together to network, pitch, watch new films and series, talk shop and take tentative steps towards possible dealmaking while the first spring rains sift from the Cape Town sky.

As the most visitors yet for this annual film festival - held under the aegis of MultiChoice and M-Net's Afrikaans content division - gather this week at the seaside resort suburb colloquially called "Cannes in Cape Town", a lot of the hubbub at the Silwerskermfees this year is around its pivot to broaden and include television.

While TV's wheelers and dealers have always been present at the Silwerskermfilmfees, kykNET is formally incorporating TV into its weeklong schedule for the first time this year, similar to how the Berlin International Film Festival and others globally have given a window at their festivals to the big and small screen alike.

In a first, festivalgoers and the media will get to attend screenings of three TV pilots of upcoming series on kykNET and MultiChoice's Showmax streamer: Die Brug, Juffrou X and Spinners.

Spinners for instance - a gritty Cape Flats set drama series about a teenager motor car racer trying to escape a culture of gang violence - as a Showmax Original co-production with Canal+, is the first such type of co-production of its kind in South Africa.

"Several of the big festivals have expanded to include TV," Nicola van Niekerk, MultiChoice's head of premium content and co-productions, tells TVwithThinus.

"Something like SXSW ("South by Southwest") in Austin, Texas is the idea and direction we want to take the Silwerskermfees and what we want to grow it into in the future."

"SXSW is for movies, documentaries, for TV, for digital content - it's a content creator market and that's what we're moving towards with Silwerskerm - for anything made and done in Afrikaans. For all of that kykNET is planting and raising the flag."

No film festival remains static, says Waldimar Pelser, M-Net director for premium channels, who tells TVwithThinus he's looking forward to seeing the reaction from festivalgoers to this year's expanded content slate.

"We remain committed to film but have expanded into including short documentary films. It's the first time we're moving beyond scripted at the fest and I'm looking forward to seeing whether there are local filmmakers seeing a future for themselves within this genre."

"The other expansion is to selectively include TV as part of the festival," he says.

"Our dream is - as has been the case with the film festival over the past decade - to look back a few years from now and be able to point to producers and other talent who will then be making shows for kykNET and other places, who were able to benefit from mentorship at the festival or got help to compile something like a pitch deck for their proposals."




Pitching support in big demand
At the year's film fest, a master class on directing, as well as multiple sessions and workshops - including specific "pitch to us" sessions for drama series, documentaries, as well as reality and entertainment - all offering help for how to properly do better pitches  - have all been fully booked for weeks before the start of the festival today.

"If I had a rand for every producer who's said to me 'We've submitted so many pitches and we constantly just get no upon no I would be a millionaire by now," says Nicola.

"Everybody wants to make television. We see about 2 000 submissions at M-Net per month. If your pitch document and how you're telling your story within those first few pages are not done correctly, you're lessening your chances tremendously to be successful."

"We just thought about these people submitting time and time after time and they're not successful - yet they have everything that's needed and required. But they don't know how a proper pitch document is supposed to look. They don't know how to talk during a pitch meeting and how to sell their idea."

"We thought: Let's start to help the wider industry with this as well because eventually it will help everyone. Otherwise you keep getting no, no, no from people and there's no growth."

Nicola says kykNET and the wider industry are looking for new talent.

"We thought: Let us help up-and-coming talent to enable them to communicate their ideas better to executives. It's exactly because it is so difficult that people are so interested in attending the Silwerskermfees to come and learn how to be better at it."

Nicola says the 11th Silwerskermfees will definitely be the biggest one yet in terms of attendees. 

"We've registered more people than ever before. That we're opening it up to television as well, is bringing even more people into the fold. In 10 years of this festival we've never had a waiting list before which we have this year for the first time." 


SA film biz is alive with possibilities
"That there are five new feature-length films in Afrikaans making their debut at this year's 11th Silwerskermfees is an absolute blessing for the industry and for viewers," says Nicola van Niekerk.

"With some, it was down to the line that some might not have been ready in time. I'm just so glad about the quality. We also tried to build and establish some new business models around these films so that it's worthwhile for everyone," she says.

"What people don't realise - and what remains challenging - is for Afrikaans films to get made in South Africa. Afrikaans consumers have always been very loyal, going to the cinema to go and watch and support Afrikaans film. But with the Covid pandemic that machine broke," she explains.

For her, kykNET's Silwerskermfees film festival continues to help create buzz and to build excitement around the intangible quality of perception that South Africa's industry remains vibrant and worthwhile. 

"The Silwerskerm film festival brings people together and focuses the excitement about making film and television, and how great it is to work in film and television in South Africa despite its many challenges," she says.

"Something like Silwerskerm helps to keep the local film biz alive - not just Afrikaans film but the entire spectrum of the value chain. It keeps it going."

"It's also a showcase for the global biz of what South Africa has and can do - to show the world that they can come here and film and do their projects here," she says.

"We have everything that's needed. We've built it. We've created it. We're not resting on our laurels. South Africa's film industry exists and the Silwerskermfees is the showcase that it's alive."

The grey and the gone to steal the limelight at kykNET's 11th Silwerskermfees.


Thinus Ferreira

It's a foregone conclusion that the biggest buzz on the blue carpet at the 11th kykNET Silwerskermfees film festival this year will revolve around a few grey legends and a shocking empty space.

When kykNET's annual film festival kicks off in Cape Town on Wednesday it will be the silver-haired cast of Hans Steek die Rubicon Oor (Hans Crosses the Rubicon) who will be stealing the spotlight, as well as Frankie & Felipé's Bradley Olivier who died last month. 

While it's usually the wrinkle-free faces in South Africa's film and TV biz capturing the clicks of the cameras, it's a new film with a few Afrikaans golden oldies - as well as a soap star who is suddenly no longer there - who will largely monopolise the media attention this year.

Demarcated media space next to the blue carpet is already hard to come by and seats in the Bay-hotel's Rotunda even less for Wednesday's Silwerskermfees première of Hans Steek die Rubicon Oor with veteran actors Pierre van Pletzen, Tobie Cronjé, June van Merch and Sandra Prinsloo.

The film from the filmmaking pair Corné and René van Rooyen's Red Letter Day Pictures who are also responsible for the script and directing, is based on crime writer Rudie van Rensburg's similarly titled book which was a massive hit on radio as an Afrikaans serial read by Cronjé on the SABC's RSG.

Now a hilarious Van Pletzen plays the obstinate and creative 90-year-old Hans, dumped in the old-age home Huis Carpe Diem by his estranged daughter from which he hatches plans to escape. It's here where the energetic senior citizen causes chaos with everything from cannabis cakes to strippers and even leads an old-age revolt under the residents.

In the big screen version, Cronjé plays Vasie, with June van Merch as Baby, Sandra Prinsloo as Liesbet and Nicola Hanekom as the militant Matron who is a retired jail warden.

The kykNET Films movie opens on 29 September at cinemas with the top billing stars in this feisty adventure comedy caper who are older than 70 but are expected to pull family audiences from young to old to cinemas.

The other feature film that will demand attention is the heartfelt comedy Frankie & Felipé due to the main co-star whose place on the blue carpet will be conspicuously empty.

Bradley Olivier (36), known as the paramedic Danny in kykNET's Binnelanders soap unexpectedly passed away last month from a brain aneurysm.

Olivier, in a powerful performance as Franklin Blaze, appears alongside comedian Solomon Cupido as Felipé in this comedy - the first film they've made under their Sturvey Pictures production banner. Besides co-producers, they were also co-writers of the film together with the Safta award-winning scriptwriter Brett Michael Innes.

In the film with Marvin-Lee Beukes as director, the two adult half brothers reunite just before Frankie's upcoming wedding, with the dodgy Felipé who owes some unscrupulous characters money and now risks tarnishing Frankie's reputation as a successful businessman.

Kim Syster is seen as Frankie's fiance, with Zane Meas and Ilse Klink as the future inlaws.

At Thursday's Silwerskermfees debut of Frankie & Felipé the media will have a lot of questions for his co-stars about Olivier, with the stars who will have to walk a fine line with valiant smiles to try and prevent a melancholic première atmosphere.

This year's Silwerskermfees film festival will include for the first time also the premières of six documentary films which were developed and produced by kykNET as part of a mentorship programme with Idea Candy.

The documentaries include Besmet, Born Behind Bars, Call of the Wild, Langafstand, 'n Gids vir Louzanne and Teater na die Mense.

Besides vyf new feature films, 14 short films and the six documentaries, the pilot episodes of upcoming new local TV series will also be shown to the media for the first time at the festival.

These include Die Brug, kykNET's new reality competition show done by Red Pepper Pictures, as well as the gritty new kykNET drama series Juffrou X headlined by Trix Viviers and set at the fictional and problem-filled Victory Heights high school.

Then there's also Spinners, a new drama series from MultiChoice's Showmax video streaming service that revolves around a rubber-circle burning drag racing teenager from the Cape Flats trying to escape a life of gangsterism through motorsport.

This year's Silwerskermfees award ceremony with a thousand invited guests will take place on Saturday evening in the Cape Town International Convention Centre (CTICC) where kykNET TV shows will also be included as category prizes and honoured.

The glitzy awards show will be broadcast on kykNET on Sunday night.

Sunday’s Carte Blanche will be an hourlong Derek Watts tribute episode.


by Thinus Ferreira

His longtime former colleagues Devi Sankaree Govender and Ruda Landman might very well return to the Carte Blanche studio this Sunday evening on M-Net (DStv 101) at 19:00 when the whole hour of the show will be a tribute episode to Derek Watts who died earlier this week after losing his battle against cancer.

Today kykNET (DStv 144) will rebroadcast a sit-down interview with Derek Watts when the episode of Hannes Aan Huis in which Hannes van Wyk talks to Watts at his home, will be shown again at 17:30.

Meanwhile, behind-the-scenes the Combined Artistic Productions show has immediately started to rework Sunday's entire episode as a tribute programme to Derek Watts.

John Webb, Carte Blanche executive producer, says that an hour feels like too little time to honour and showcase Watts' massive contribution but we're going to try our best.

Devi Sankaree Govender told TVwithThinus that few people are aware that Derek Watts "hated doing confrontational interviews. He hated it with an absolute passion and I had no idea about this because I was watching Derek from the time I was 15 years old when Carte Blanche started".

"I never would have guessed that. I joined Carte Blanche in 2002 and I just had this leaning towards catching the crooks and the bad guys and it was just something that I loved doing."

"It didn't take Derek long before he came up to me the one day and he said: 'I'm so happy that you do these stories and you do it so well because it means I don't really have to do it because I don't like confronting people - it makes me feel awkward."

"The thing with Derek is that he was just genuinely such a nice guy. He was the real deal. He actually felt bad for the skelms. He always remarked on that he just really found it difficult. He did ask the thought questions in his own way and he was always able to get answers out of people in a very gentle, almost kind, kind of way."

"He never like the confrontations and in a way we bonded over my confrontations because he was just so grateful and always acknowledged it when I did great work which I appreciated as a young journalist just starting out."

"I got to work with my television icon - one of the people along with Ruda Landman and Manu Padayachee, so I know I was the lucky one." 


Tuesday, August 22, 2023

Veteran Carte Blanche anchor Derek Watts dead at 74 after losing his battle against cancer.


by Thinus Ferreira

The veteran anchor of Carte Blanche on M-Net (DStv 101), Derek Watts died Tuesday morning surrounded by his family after losing his battle against cancer. He was 74.

Derek Watts who was born on 24 November 1948 died on Tuesday morning after he was diagnosed with skin cancer last year which had since spread to his lungs. He is survived by his wife Belinda and his children Tyrone and Kirsty.

Derek Watts was part of the Combined Artistic Productions show since its inception in 1988 on M-Net and over decades became one of the country's most respected interviewers and investigative journalists. 

I'm told Sunday night's episode of Carte Blanche will be dedicated to Derek Watts.

After initially saying that he planned to return to Carte Blanche when he was feeling better when he told viewers about his cancer diagnosis, last month Derek Watts said that he will never be returning to Carte Blanche again.

His daughter Kirsty said "we are devastated, he was the most wonderful person we knew".

"He always thought of other people and yesterday evening he said he would like to thank all the viewers. He appreciated him and loved his work."

After privately battling cancer since 2022, with the support of his family and specialists, Derek Watts was able to continue presenting Carte Blanche.

In March however, he got a sepsis infection which complicated his cancer treatment. The sepsis led him to collapse and he ended up in hospital having to learn to walk again.

In June, Derek Watts made a taped recording from his Netcare hospital bed in which he revealed his cancer battle to Carte Blanche viewers for the first time and noted that he definitely planned to return to the show when he's better.

In a statement, Combined Artistic Productions says "It is with profound sadness that we confirm the passing of Carte Blanche anchor and icon, Derek Watts. He passed away peacefully on Tuesday morning surrounded by loved ones".

"Our heartfelt condolences go out to his wife and children in this time of loss. He will forever hold a special place in the hearts and minds of his Carte Blanche family."

In a statement, Nomsa Philiso, MultiChoice CEO for general entertainment, says "MultiChoice extends its heartfelt condolences and deepest sympathies to the family, friends, and loved ones of the late, Derek Watts".

"We remember him as a dedicated investigative journalist and a longstanding presenter of Carte Blanche. His unwavering commitment to his work and his determination in the face of challenges were truly remarkable."

"Our thoughts and prayers are with his family during this difficult time. May they find solace in the cherished memories they shared and may Derek's legacy continue to inspire us all."


Friday, August 18, 2023

eMedia's e.tv channels to stay on MultiChoice's DStv for another few months after latest Competition Appeal Court decision.


by Thinus Ferreira

The set of eMedia's e.tv TV channels that MultiChoice wants to remove must remain on DStv for another couple of months and possibly until the end of 2023, with MultiChoice still not allowed to axe the eExtra, eToonz, eMovies or eMovies Extra channels after the Competition Appeal Court granted eMedia a further extension.

South Africa's Competition Appeal Court granted another extension for e.tv's channels to remain on DStv for the time being, ordering MultiChoice to keep the four TV channels on DStv, until the conclusion of the Competition Tribunal's latest decision on the drawn-out case.

After originally wanting to remove eMedia's set of TV channels from DStv at the end of March 2022, MultiChoice was finally planning to axe eMedia's channels at the end of July 2023 as the latest switch-off date in the e.tv-on-DStv-e.tv-off-DStv case which has been ongoing for over a year.

After channel carriage renewal negotiations broke down last year, MultiChoice decided that it no longer wanted to continue carrying eMedia Investments' eMovies (DStv 138), eMovies Extra (DStv 140), eExtra (DStv 195) and eToonz (DStv 311) TV channels.

MultiChoice did opt to keep – under a separate agreement – the TV news channel eNCA (DStv 403) and e.tv (DStv 194) also from eMedia, which includes the 7-days a week eNuus Afrikaans TV news bulletin packaged by eNCA and supplied to M-Net's kykNET (DStv 144) and kykNET & Kie (DStv 145) channels.

The four e.tv-packaged channels were all set to go dark at the end of March 2022 on DStv but the Competition Commission ordered MultiChoice to keep the channels for the time being until the case was heard. 

The Tribunal heard the case in April 2022 and dismissed it. MultiChoice dropped the e.tv channels at the end of May 2022.

MultiChoice told the Competition Tribunal during hearings in April 2022 that it had satellite transponder capacity constraints and that eMedia's TV channels didn't fit into its 5-year strategy. eMedia showed that MultiChoice did have enough satellite capacity.

After MultiChoice dropped the channels at the end of May 2022, eMedia then took MultiChoice to the Competition Tribunal again when it immediately appealed the case. MultiChoice was therefore ordered to immediately reinstate the e.tv channels for another few months pending the outcome of the appeal.

Besides DStv, the e.tv channels are available on the eMedia-owned free-to-air satellite service OpenView and with eExtra also carried on China's StarTimes operating as StarSat in South Africa. The e.tv-packaged TV channels have been some of the most-watched TV channels on DStv in South Africa. 

A Competition Commission investigation had been ongoing with eMedia alleging that "MultiChoice's conduct constitutes an abuse of dominance in contravention of the Competition Act". The Tribunal granted another extension order in December 2022 for a further period of a maximum of six months.

After the last extension granted by the Tribunal in December 2022, the eMedia channels would have been removed from DStv at the end of July 2023. In June this year, eMedia meanwhile asked MultiChoice directly for an extension or undertaking that it would not remove the e.tv channels from DStv but MultiChoice said it wouldn't agree to any such extension. 

eMedia then again sought urgent relief and once again asked for a further extension from the Competition Appeal Court for its e.tv channels to remain on MultiChoice's DStv. 

The court has now decided that MultiChoice must "maintain the status quo and is interdicted from removing the following channels from the bouquet of channels on the DStv platform of which they currently form part" while the Competition Tribunal considers whether "a further extension of interim relief can be legally justified".

TVwithThinus asked eMedia in late-July about the case with eMedia that said it had no comment.


Wednesday, August 16, 2023

TV CRITIC's NOTEBOOK: Why BET Africa's Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza bio-series feels like yet another lazy and wasted press opportunity by Paramount Africa.


by Thinus Ferreira

BET Africa's new Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza biographical drama series looks like another low-level dud from Paramount Africa, given the apparent lazy and lacklustre effort from Paramount Africa and BET to try and do proper publicity for the 6-episode series or to get any real media attention and press traction for it.

Unbeknownst to a lot of media covering TV who were not told that it would be happening, last week sometime Paramount Africa and BET held a physical premiere and screening for Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza, a dramatised series about the life of the late South African kwaito singer Mduduzi Edmond Tshabalala, which is a co-production between Biopic Films and Pomegranate Media with Wiseman Mncube in the title role.

Executive produced by Mpho Tshabalala, Mandoza's widow, and Vaugh Eaton who was his manager, Paramount Africa and BET couldn't bother with any virtual media engagement like roundtable interviews over Zoom with the cast and production, and completely failed to reach out to media to ask if they're interested in interviews or doing anything around the show.

Invited media to the premiere got to see some of the content beforehand but media not aware of the physical screening were not sent digital screeners automatically either before the premiere event or afterwards for possible review or reporting purposes.

In fact, for media not invited to the Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza media event and screening in Johannesburg there was absolutely nothing to promote the upcoming new 6-episode show - except for a single email blast to the media list on 18 July. There were no calls, no emails, no personal relationship building or communication. Nothing.

Now Paramount Africa and BET Africa expect... what? Reams of coverage, reviews, interviews and stories for Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza, directed by Zuko Nodada? How? From out of what? What effort?

Absolutely nothing was shared by Paramount Africa and BET Africa of what any of the cast or Monde Twala, senior vice president and general manager for Paramount Africa and lead for BET International said at the event. No transcripts, no recordings. 

BET isn't a Johannesburg community TV station like GauTV but while its content is seen across sub-Saharan Africa, Paramount Africa apparently couldn't involve media beyond just Johannesburg in terms of personal outreach around publicity and coverage for Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza.

It's as if Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza is some fly-by-night production done on a shoe-string budget for a community TV station. 

Will it be better, the same or worse than the BET Original Dream: The Lebo Mathosa Story? Who knows? 

Paramount Africa and BET Africa certainly didn't go out of its way in any way to try and create any impression whatsoever about it with me or with any of a handful of other journalists and critics covering television, or to get some of their time and attention to engage with this new local content.

Last week, after I surprisingly saw that BET Africa had a media event and screening for Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza I reached out to other journalists also covering BET Africa and Paramount Africa and asked them if they knew anything about it. Nobody did.

I then took the initiative to reach out to Thabo Mboweni, media specialist at Vuma Reputation Management about Paramount Africa and BET Africa's Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza

Paramount Africa pays Vuma Reputation Management to handle its corporate communications.

I asked Thabo Mboweni and Vuma Reputation Management these four questions for a report about Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza, and said answers will be published with the questions in a Q&A form.

The questions are these:

1. I saw that Paramount Africa/BET held a physical premiere and screening earlier this week but I wasn’t aware of it, or made aware of it beforehand – in other words there was no communication at all about this. Why couldn't BET tell media that there was going to be a screening or a media event in advance in order for media to do planning around it?

2. What is Paramount Africa and BET’s strategy or expectation regarding press reviews? The show was screened at the media event but what about media who wasn't there? Why does BET not make digital screeners available to media in South Africa in advance, or does BET believe the content is bad or of a low quality, or does BET want media only to watch content once it airs on TV, i.e. not before broadcast?

3. Does Paramount Africa/BET have transcripts or recordings available of what was said at the media event and screening, or how do media cover or are helped to report on what was said there?

4. Why did Paramount Africa/BET not do any roundtable interviews with the cast/crew for media?

Thabo Mboweni said he would forward the media query to the Total Exposure PR agency "who handles the brand channels". This was on Thursday last week. There's not been any specific answers to any of these specific questions I raised, to publish with these questions.

Natalie Mdladla, senior director of communications at Paramount Africa, emailed to say that Paramount Africa does plan to share an episode with media who were not at the event. Natalie said that the episode was only delivered on Tuesday afternoon and that a viewing link will be shared.

Images from the launch event were shared as a download link. The speech that Mpho Tshabalala gave was shared. Monde Twala's speech wasn't shared.

A rundown was shared of what happened at Paramount Africa and BET Africa's Nkalakatha: The Life of Mandoza event:
 
  • Started with a speech from Monde Twala who spoke to how special the project is to us and how important it is that we tell our heroes’ stories. He thanked Mpho Tshabalala and Vaughn Eaton (Mandoza’s manager) for their guidance, he thanked our partners; production companies, Biopic Films and Pomegranate Media and the DTIC.
  • Screening of the first episode
  • Speech by Mpho Tshabalala (her three children Tokollo, Tumelo and Karabo joined her on stage)
  • Performance by Mandoza’s son Tumelo (stage name is Harry). He performed ‘Soweto Boy’. He is following in his father’s footsteps and his mom is his manager.
  • Performance by Chizkop cast (Wiseman Mncube, Fanele Zulu, Lindo Sithole) and original Chizkop member Mfana “Montigo” Sithebe. They performed Nkalakatha and Abasazi.

Tuesday, August 15, 2023

South Africa's stream wars: It's on like Donkey Kong for Netflix, Showmax and Amazon Prime Video in Africa battling it out for subs by 2029 with Disney+ in 4th place.


by Thinus Ferreira

The battle for streaming in South Africa and eventually across the rest of the African continent is basically a three-horse race, with Netflix, MultiChoice's Showmax and Amazon Prime Video which will be the big three battling it out for stream TV supremacy.

Disney+ from the Mouse House will be in 4th place as the group of video streaming services battling to add subscribers are set to collectively add another 10 million customers over the next six years.

According to the latest market research and projections from Digital TV Research, the number of subscription video-on-demand (SVOD) subscribers in Africa is expected to reach a whopping 18 million by 2029 - up 8 million subscribers six years from now, compared to the end of this year.

Video streaming penetration is however expected to remain low in Africa by 2029 at just 7.7% of TV households who will be subscribing to at least one streaming service by then.


According to Digital TV Research's latest projections, the biggest video streamer in Africa will be Netflix with 7.55 million subscribers by 2029. Netflix is expected to add 3.4 million subscribers from this year. 

Netflix will be followed by Showmax, with MultiChoice which plans to unveil a retooled "Showmax 2.0" at the end of this year done in partnership with Comcast's NBCUniversal. 

Showmax will reach 4.4 million subscribers by adding another 3 million, while Amazon Prime Video will hit 3.14 million subscribers, with Disney+ in fourth place with 1.54 million subscribers. Apple TV+ trails with 251 000 subscribers by 2029 across Africa.

Paramount Global's Paramount+ is still to launch in South Africa, while Warner Bros. Discovery has also been silent about a launch date for its rebranded Max, previously HBO Max, which is not yet available in South Africa.

Ntokozo Khumalo of Newzroom Afrika, Tshepo Mongoa of SABC News, and others went on an all-expenses paid Karpowership trip to Rio de Janeiro and failed to tell viewers it was a Brazil freebie and promotional coverage.


by Thinus Ferreira

South African TV news journalists like Ntokozo Khumalo of Newzroom Afrika (DStv 405), Tshepo Mongoa of SABC News (DStv 404), and 4 others like Sizwe Sama Yende at City Press went on an all-expenses paid Karpowership to Rio de Janeiro and failed to tell viewers that the coverage was in fact promotional Karpowership coverage due to a freebie Brazil trip.

Nowhere in her story did Ntokozo Khumalo tell DStv subscribers watching the TV news channel that Newzroom Afrika was talking to people Karpowership publicists gave the TV news channel access to in Brazil and wanted Newzroom Afrika to talk to.

Neither did Ntokozo Khumalo or Newzroom Afrika tell viewers that the Brazil visit was part of an all-expenses paid, free trip that was offered to Newzroom Afrika and that Newzroom Afrika agreed to.

While it looks like Ntokozo Khumalo is doing real reporting, the Newzroom Afrika coverage in fact spins Karpowership's involvement as hilariously positive - going as far as even interviewing about the environmental projects Karpowership is paying for, to showcase how allegedly positive and great a Karpowership deal would be to supply South Africa with electricity.

The same goes for SABC News and Tshepo Mongoa of SABC News - with the public broadcaster that likewise deliberately omitted to tell viewers in Tshepo Mongoa's story filed from Rio de Janeiro that the SABC News "reporting" was made possible by Karpowership and is therefore actually a Karpowership promo and something Karpowership paid for in terms of sponsoring a free overseas trip.

Annika Larsen co-incidentally also aired a Karpowership interview she conducted in Turkey for her My Guest Tonight with Annika Larsen show on eNCA (DStv 403) and e.tv, but made it quite clear that "we paid for our trip to Turkey in full interest of unbiased journalism".

"We were not aware Karpowership was taking journalists on a junket when we booked," Annika Larsen said.

TVwithThinus reached out to the South African National Editors' Forum (SANEF) for comment, which will be added here when received.

M-Net hasn't spoken to the press collectively about its content in over 3 years and counting - but says it plans to, again.


by Thinus Ferreira

While M-Net has kept courting advertisers with annual shindigs to crow about its existing and upcoming content, MultiChoice's blue-ribbon channel and the rest of its premium channels division hasn't held press court and presented or spoken to the media collectively in over three and a half years.

It's something that has been rankling the media covering television in South Africa, left wondering what's going on and why M-Net stopped interacting with journalists in this way.

It's been over 3 and a half years since February 2020 which was when M-Net last bothered to invite media to any kind of showcase or upfront presentation, to show and tell the media about its content and upcoming programming, to do any roving mic Q&A sessions with executives and talent, and to show sizzle reels and talk about its schedules and acquisitions.

The disappearance of M-Net's centre court get-togethers with media directly ties into the evaporation of a lot of the constant coverage and top billing press that DStv's 101 channel got in previous years - with several media that moved on and got their attention stolen by video streaming services like Netflix, Disney+ and others that moved into the vacuum M-Net left as the new shiny baubles on the TV Christmas tree hogging press attention. 

While M-Net has dropped and not done any upfront or showcase events either virtually during the Covid-19 pandemic or in-person over the past three years with media, M-Net has kept doing its annual showcase session with advertisers. 

The latest one where M-Net invited and met with advertisers and ad buyers collectively in-person took place on 29 June in Johannesburg. 

Since February 2020 which was the last time M-Net got the media together to showcase its international and latest local content slate and to take questions, M-Net has lost its entire top executive block in a massive seachange with all of the people who used to appear before the press who have moved away and on.

The highly experienced and well-known publicist Lani Lombard exited M-Net in mid-September 2020 after 25 years who was responsible for and spearheaded numerous M-Net media events and M-Net showcase and upfront presentations.

The veteran and highly respected M-Net boss Jan du Plessis had to retire at the end of March 2023 and was then snapped up to lead Primedia Studios

Meanwhile, top-programmer and executive Tracy-Ann van Rooyen left M-Net in mid-2021 for The Walt Disney Company Africa where the media-favourite has gone on to appear and present about upcoming content in front of the collective media multiple times in both online and in-person presentations, and to take questions.

Then there's the sparkling and highly capable former M-Net exec Kaye Ann Williams who also left M-Net in the latter part of 2022 where she headed up local productions and independent films, to become the head of scripted series and movies at Amazon Prime Video in South Africa.

This institutional M-Net quartet - Jan du Plessis, Tracy-Ann van Rooyen, Kaye Ann Williams and Lani Lombard - all gone - were, together, the face of M-Net 101 in the auditorium whenever M-Net got the media together.




Journalists covering South African television and the TV industry say that they don't know why M-Net stopped interacting with the press group through collective events and haven't done any collective upfront since February 2020, that they no longer have any "feel" for or familiarity with who the top people are now running M-Net, and no longer has an accurate sense for where M-Net is or its place within the broader TV landscape.

An experienced newspaper journalist who has covered M-Net (DStv 101) and the other M-Net channels for many years told TVwithThinus that M-Net's decrease in collective media interaction and the lack of in-person events and upfronts has led to a decrease in the perception of the stature it once had.

"I believe that the showcases added so much value. Aside from helping us (journalists) keep abreast with new and upcoming shows, it also helped us with planning and we got to interact with the PR team on more than just an email or telephonic basis," the person notes.

"We knew the team and it helped us when communicating about shows. Nowadays when we send an email, we get an automated reply saying "expect a delayed response". I would say M-Net has lost the stature it once had."

"Now that things have changed and we have not been notified, it's definitely harder to plan interviews. The team does not even reach out to say if anyone is available nor do they offer press packs or transcripts of any sort."

"I honestly focus on streaming channels nowadays because information is ready when you need it. On a deadline-driven day, it is hard to wait for information."




Another media practitioner who has covered M-Net and its content for many years and was included and attended numerous M-Net physical and virtual media events previously, notes that M-Net has been seceding not just top-of-mind space but press space.

"M-Net's increased lack of engagement with the SA media covering TV and entertainment for over three years in the form of showcases and programming events is quite concerning," the journalist says.

"Engaging with the media through events like showcases is common practice in the TV industry. It allows networks to present their upcoming programming line-up, share exciting shows and create buzz among both the media and the audience. By not holding such events for the media, M-Net is losing valuable opportunities to generate positive coverage."

"During early lockdown, under the reign of Lani Lombard, head of publicity, M-Net still made an effort to host virtual events, creating buzz with promotional packs to create awareness and media involvement."

"Pushing out press releases without any form of engagement suggests M-Net no longer recogsnise and value the importance of fostering and maintaining relationships with media partners. One can only wonder what M-Net's underlying motivation are."

"When a major network like M-Net fails to engage with the media, it prevents the exchange of information, and the sharing of the network's planned programming and pipeline developments for the coming period."

"M-Net's "decision" to discontinue showcase events for content and upcoming shows, coupled with the media no longer knowing the current M-Net executives since the departure of Jan du Plessis at the end of March and Waldimar Pelser stepping into the role of head of both M-net and kykNET channels in April, raises concerns about the networks' communication strategy providing media representatives with first-hand access to upcoming content, and opportunities to interact with key executives and talent."

"Merely pushing out a press release with no direct engagement means that M-Net is missing out on valuable opportunities to generate excitement and interest in shows among the media and the viewing public."

"As a journalist, it would be interesting to understand the reasons behind M-Net's decision and underlying motivations, as 2023 specifically has seen very little, if any, drive to create excitement and buzz with media partners," he says.

"No sneak peeks or series-branded press packs to build anticipation and encourage media coverage to generate interest. One can only ask, is the future as a media partner with M-Net going to be a bleak one?" 

Another longtime journalist who has covered M-Net for many years, says M-Net should at least have kept doing the same when it comes to personalised media interaction - not less - and should have kept up with the times as streamers flooded in "to take M-Net's crown".

"Amazon Prime Video and Netflix SA and Disney+ and other channels that used to be far lower in terms of prestige and press attention are seen to be doing things and constantly trying to one-up each other when they get the media together and showcase their content."

"It feels as if M-Net oddly sat back and has just let them take its crown. Isn't M-Net supposed to be DStv's 101 at the top? You wouldn't think that anymore." 

TVwithThinus put the following questions in a media query to M-Net after its Disrupt M-Net 2023 showcase event for advertisers on 29 June: Why hasn't M-Net done any showcase/upfront for media either in person or online since February 2020?

It's been over 3 years with nothing for journalists in the way that M-Net used to liaise and interact with media by showcasing upcoming content, making announcements and doing Q&As. M-Net is interacting with ad buyers and advertisers. What is the difference and why is M-Net no longer doing the same with media as with ad buyers?

A M-Net representative responded to the questions by saying that M-Net is planning another M-Net showcase for media and is working on exciting and exclusive media previews.